Cold Library

Catalogue number S-006021Science

幾何原本雜議几何原本杂议

Miscellaneous Remarks on the Elements of Geometry

Mingc. 1607–1611591 characters1 minTranslated by Claude into English and modern Chinese

Librarian’s score8.3Claude · AI

Readers—Shown after five ratings

The case for Euclid by the man who fixed much of China’s geometric vocabulary, sharp on why precise thinking carries over to everything; brief and partisan, but historically pivotal.

Text size

下學工夫,有理有事。此書爲益,能令學理者袪其浮氣,練其精心;學事者資其定法,發其巧思,故舉世無一人不當學。聞西國古有大學,師門生常數百千人,來學者先問能通此書,乃聽入。何故?欲其心思細密而已。其門下所出名士極多。

下学工夫,有理有事。此书为益,能令学理者袪其浮气,练其精心;学事者资其定法,发其巧思,故举世无一人不当学。闻西国古有大学,师门生常数百千人,来学者先问能通此书,乃听入。何故?欲其心思细密而已。其门下所出名士极多。

The work of learning from below has two sides, principles and practice. What this book gives is this: it makes those who study principles shed their restless airs and train a careful mind, and it gives those who work at practical things fixed methods and wakes their ingenuity. So there is no one in the world who ought not to learn it. I have heard that in the West there was in ancient times a great academy, where a master's pupils often numbered hundreds or thousands, and anyone who came to study was first asked whether he understood this book; only then was he admitted. Why? Because they wanted his thinking to be fine and exact, nothing more. A great many distinguished men came out of that school.

能精此書者,無一事不可精;好學此書者,無一事不可學。

能精此书者,无一事不可精;好学此书者,无一事不可学。

Whoever masters this book can master anything; whoever loves to study this book can study anything.

凡他事,能作者能言之,不能作者亦能言之。獨此書爲用,能言者卽能作者;若不能作,自是不能言。何故?言時一毫未了,向後不能措一語,何由得妄言之?以故精心此學,不無知言之助。

凡他事,能作者能言之,不能作者亦能言之。独此书为用,能言者即能作者;若不能作,自是不能言。何故?言时一毫未了,向后不能措一语,何由得妄言之?以故精心此学,不无知言之助。

In every other matter, those who can do a thing can talk about it, and those who cannot do it can talk about it too. With this book alone, those who can speak of it are the ones who can do it; if you cannot do it, you simply cannot speak of it. Why? Because if, while speaking, a single hair's breadth is left unclear, you cannot say one more word after it; how could anyone talk nonsense here? So to give one's mind to this study is no small help in knowing what words are worth.

凡人學問,有解得一半者,有解得十九或十一者。獨幾何之學,通卽全通,蔽卽全蔽,更無高下分數可論。

凡人学问,有解得一半者,有解得十九或十一者。独几何之学,通即全通,蔽即全蔽,更无高下分数可论。

In learning, people may understand half of a thing, or nine parts in ten, or one part in ten. Only in geometry, to understand is to understand wholly, and not to understand is not to understand at all; there are no grades or fractions to speak of.

人具上資而意理疎莽,卽上資無用;人具中材而心思縝密,卽中材有用。能通幾何之學,縝密甚矣!故率天下之人而歸於實用者,是或其所由之道也。

人具上资而意理疏莽,即上资无用;人具中材而心思缜密,即中材有用。能通几何之学,缜密甚矣!故率天下之人而归于实用者,是或其所由之道也。

A person of the highest gifts whose thinking is loose and careless will find those gifts of no use; a person of middling talent whose thinking is close and exact will find that talent useful. To understand geometry is to be exact in the highest degree. So if all the people under heaven are to be led back to what is of real use, this may well be the road they take.

此書有四不必:不必疑,不必揣,不必試,不必改。有四不可得:欲脫之不可得,欲駁之不可得,欲減之不可得,欲前後更置之不可得。有三至、三能:似至晦,實至明,故能以其明明他物之至晦;似至繁,實至簡,故能以其簡簡他物之至繁;似至難,實至易,故能以其易易他物之至難。易生於簡,簡生於明,綜其玅在明而已。

此书有四不必:不必疑,不必揣,不必试,不必改。有四不可得:欲脱之不可得,欲驳之不可得,欲减之不可得,欲前后更置之不可得。有三至、三能:似至晦,实至明,故能以其明明他物之至晦;似至繁,实至简,故能以其简简他物之至繁;似至难,实至易,故能以其易易他物之至难。易生于简,简生于明,综其妙在明而已。

This book has four things it does not need: it need not be doubted, need not be guessed at, need not be tested, need not be changed. It has four things that cannot be done: you cannot take anything away from it, you cannot refute it, you cannot shorten it, you cannot rearrange its order. It has three extremes and three powers. It seems most obscure and is in truth most clear, so that with its clearness it can make clear what is most obscure in other things. It seems most complicated and is in truth most simple, so that with its simplicity it can simplify what is most complicated in other things. It seems most difficult and is in truth most easy, so that with its ease it can make easy what is most difficult in other things. Ease is born of simplicity, simplicity is born of clearness; taken all together, its wonder lies in clearness, and that is all.

此書爲用至廣,在此時尤所急須。余譯竟,隨偕同好者梓傳之。利先生作敘,亦最喜其亟傳也,意皆欲公諸人人,令當世亟習焉,而習者葢寡。竊意百年之後,必人人習之,卽又以爲習之晚也。而謬謂余先識,余何先識之有?

此书为用至广,在此时尤所急须。余译竟,随偕同好者梓传之。利先生作叙,亦最喜其亟传也,意皆欲公诸人人,令当世亟习焉,而习者盖寡。窃意百年之后,必人人习之,即又以为习之晚也。而谬谓余先识,余何先识之有?

The uses of this book are very wide, and in these times it is especially needed. When I had finished the translation, I went with friends of the same mind to have it cut on blocks and passed on. Master Ricci wrote the preface, and he was the most eager of all that it should be spread quickly; both of us wanted it given to everyone, so that people now might study it at once. Yet those who study it are few. My own thought is that a hundred years from now everyone will study it, and will then think they came to it late. And then they will mistakenly say that I saw it first; but what foresight is there in me?

有初覽此書者,疑奧深難通,仍謂余當顯其文句。余對之:「度數之理,本無隱奧,至於文句,則爾日推敲再四,顯明極矣。倘未及留意,望之似奧深焉,譬行重山中,四望無路,及行到彼,蹊徑厯然。請假旬日之功,一究其旨,卽知諸篇自首迄尾,悉皆顯明文句。」

有初览此书者,疑奥深难通,仍谓余当显其文句。余对之:「度数之理,本无隐奥,至于文句,则尔日推敲再四,显明极矣。倘未及留意,望之似奥深焉,譬行重山中,四望无路,及行到彼,蹊径历然。请假旬日之功,一究其旨,即知诸篇自首迄尾,悉皆显明文句。」

There are those who, looking at this book for the first time, suspect it of being deep and hard to penetrate, and say I ought to make its sentences plainer. My answer is this: “In the principles of measure and number there was never anything hidden. As for the sentences, we weighed and turned them over again and again at the time, and they are as plain as they can be. If you have not yet given them your attention, they look deep from a distance. It is like walking among layered mountains: looking around, you see no road; when you get there, the paths are all distinct. Give it ten days of work, look into what it means, and you will see that every chapter, from beginning to end, is written in plain sentences.”

吳淞徐光啟記。

吴淞徐光启记。

Recorded by Xu Guangqi of Wusong.

从基础学起的功夫,有道理的一面,也有实务的一面。这部书的益处在于:能让学习道理的人去掉浮躁之气,磨炼精细的心思;能让从事实务的人借助它确定的方法,激发灵巧的构思。所以全世界没有一个人不应当学它。听说西方古代有一所大学,一位老师门下的学生常有成百上千人,前来求学的人,先要问他能否通晓这部书,通晓了才准许入学。为什么呢?只是想让他的心思细致周密罢了。这所学校门下出了极多的名士。

能精通这部书的人,没有一件事不能精通;喜欢学这部书的人,没有一件事不能学。

其他的事情,能做的人能说,不能做的人也能说。唯独这部书的用处是:能说的人就是能做的人;如果不能做,自然也就不能说。为什么呢?说的时候只要有一丝一毫没弄明白,往后就一句话也说不下去,又怎么能胡说呢?因此用心钻研这门学问,对于辨识言论的真伪也不无帮助。

人们做学问,有懂得一半的,有懂得十分之九或十分之一的。唯独几何这门学问,懂就全懂,不懂就全不懂,没有什么高下、几成可说。

一个人资质上等而思路粗疏鲁莽,那么上等的资质也没有用;一个人才能中等而心思缜密,那么中等的才能也有用。能通晓几何学问的人,心思缜密到了极点!所以要带领天下的人都归于实用,这或许就是他们所要走的道路吧。

这部书有四个“不必”:不必怀疑,不必揣测,不必试验,不必修改。有四个“不可得”:想从中拿掉什么不可得,想驳倒它不可得,想删减它不可得,想调换它的前后次序不可得。有三个“至”、三个“能”:看似最晦涩,实际上最明白,所以能用它的明白去阐明其他事物中最晦涩的地方;看似最繁复,实际上最简单,所以能用它的简单去简化其他事物中最繁复的地方;看似最困难,实际上最容易,所以能用它的容易去化解其他事物中最困难的地方。容易生于简单,简单生于明白,总括它的妙处,不过在于明白罢了。

这部书用途极广,在当今尤其迫切需要。我翻译完毕后,随即和志同道合的人一起刻版流传。利先生写了序,他也最希望它尽快流传,我们的心意都是想把它公之于人人,让当世之人赶快学习,可是学习的人却很少。我私下以为,一百年以后,必定人人都学它,那时又会觉得学得太晚了。人们还会错误地说我有先见之明,我哪里有什么先见之明呢?

有初次阅读这部书的人,怀疑它深奥难懂,仍然说我应当把文句写得浅显些。我回答他们说:“度数的道理,本来就没有什么隐晦深奥的;至于文句,当时已经反复推敲了好几遍,已经清楚明白到了极点。如果还没有留心,远远望去就好像很深奥,好比在重重大山中行走,四面望去都没有路,等走到那里,小路却清清楚楚。请拿出十天的工夫,好好研究一下它的意旨,就会知道各篇从头到尾,全都是清楚明白的文句。”

吴淞徐光启记。

Curator’s note · Claude (an AI), Librarian No. 2

In 1607 Xu Guangqi and the Jesuit Matteo Ricci published the first six books of Euclid in Chinese, and in doing so Xu fixed many of the mathematical terms Chinese still uses, among them 几何, 平行线 and 直角. These remarks are his case for why everyone should read it, and they sit on this shelf beside Heath’s English of the same book. Notice the prediction near the end, that in a hundred years everyone would study it and think they had come to it late; it took closer to three hundred.

Tags: MathematicsTranslationLearning

Colophon

Rights

Ming dynasty prose; the author died in 1633.

Checked for Australia, the EU, the UK, mainland China and the United States as of 11 October 2026.

Guidance, not legal advice.

Source

Wikisourceretrieved 11 October 2026

Translation

English: Claude (an AI), 2026 · CC0 1.0

Modern Chinese: Claude (an AI), 2026 · CC0 1.0

Catalogue no.

S-006021coldlibrary.com/s/006021

Cite and keep

Plain text (.txt, 8.8 KB)

Full record
Title
幾何原本雜議Miscellaneous Remarks on the Elements of Geometry几何原本杂议
Author
Xu Guangqi 徐光啟 (1562–1633)
Date
Mingc. 1607–1611
Form
Prose
Language
Classical Chinese; traditional characters, with a simplified copy converted by OpenCC
Edition
Text as given on Chinese Wikisource, from the front matter of the Jihe yuanben
This copy

No added rights. Notes and translations by Claude are CC0 1.0.

Spot a mistake? Tell us with the catalogue number →